[AI SDRs in Action] Should you send cold outreach before lunch?
Short answer: We wouldn’t shift sends to only before lunch based on this test. The 8–10 window generated 11 replies, 3 meetings, and $22.8k in HubSpot-influenced pipeline. The 12–16 window generated 10 replies, despite its higher response rate.
| Keep 8–10 if… | Test 12–16 if… |
| You need a starting schedule for cold outreach. | You have evidence that your buyers respond during lunch or afternoon breaks. |
| Meetings and pipeline matter more than the response-rate percentage. | You want to check whether break-time outreach works for your specific audience. |
| You want to reach prospects as their workday begins. | You will compare total replies, meetings, and pipeline before changing your default. |
This is part of our How AiSDR Uses AiSDR series, where we publish the wins and the misses. The full spreadsheet lives at aisdr.com/outreach-experiments/.
We expected people to notice an email early in the day, then respond when they had a break. So we compared morning sends with a later window to see whether that break-time attention would lead to more replies and, ultimately, more meetings.
Hypothesis
We expected cold emails sent in the afternoon would generate more replies than emails in the morning. That’s because prospects would have more time to respond during breaks in their workday.
Methodology
We ran an A/B test over 2 months, splitting leads between two sending windows: 8–10 and 12–16.
The audience criteria, sequence, messaging, and campaign setup were the same for both versions. The send window was the only variable we changed.
We reviewed response rates, total replies, meetings booked, and HubSpot-influenced pipeline. That let us look beyond the percentage of leads who replied and see whether either window led to more business.
Results
It was a virtual tie. The morning window got 11 replies while the afternoon window got 10, despite a slightly higher response rate.
That said, the morning window had 3 meetings booked while the afternoon had none.
| Metric | 8-10 | 12–16 |
| Total replies | 11 | 10 |
| Meetings booked | 3 | 0 |
| Response rate | 3.5% | 4.3% |
The 8–10 window also generated $22.8k in HubSpot-influenced pipeline.
Key takeaways
- Send in the morning, when the workday begins. The morning window generated 3 meetings and $22.8k in HubSpot-influenced pipeline.
- Track meetings along with replies. Total replies were almost the same, but the meetings came from the morning window.
- Treat response rate as a supporting metric. The afternoon had a higher rate, but it didn’t translate into more meetings or pipeline.
What’s next in the lab?
Next, we’ll test a send window near the end of the workday against the morning window. We’ll track replies, meetings, and pipeline to see whether sending later changes the outcomes that matter.
We’ll compare the results in the next experiment in this series.
Steal our tests
We run experiments like this connection note test every month on live campaigns, and publish the results either way.
Subscribe once, and new results reach you as each test completes.
What is the best time to send cold emails?
Our test points to 8–10 as the stronger starting window for cold emails. Send time can vary by audience, so treat morning as a starting point and test it against your own buyers.
How do you A/B test cold email send times?
Create two campaign versions and change only the sending window. Keep the audience criteria, sequence, messaging, offer, and campaign setup the same so you can connect any difference in results to send time.
How long should a sales outreach A/B test run?
Run the test long enough for both groups to complete the sequence and generate downstream results such as meetings and pipeline. Our morning-versus-afternoon test ran for 2 months.
Should cold emails follow the prospect’s local time zone?
Yes. Schedule each email according to the prospect’s local time so that 8–10 represents the start of their workday. If you target several regions, test them separately because working habits may differ.
Can one send-time test determine the best schedule for every audience?
No. Audience, role, region, and working habits can all affect when prospects respond. Use this result to choose a starting schedule, then test the same windows with your own audience before changing your default.
More experiments from the AiSDR team:
We tested morning cold outreach against lunch and early afternoon. Morning generated all 3 meetings and $22.8k in HubSpot-influenced pipeline.